Call Now! - (763) 312-0812

How to Choose the Right Shingle Color for Your Home: A Practical Guide

July 21, 2025

|

Written By: Home Front Exteriors

Home Improvement,

When it’s time for a new roof in Minnesota or Wisconsin, one of the most exciting (and often overwhelming) decisions is choosing your shingle color. The right shingle doesn’t just protect your home; it needs to handle snow, storms, and seasonal changes while boosting curb appeal and reflecting your style. This guide will delve deeper into the factors that influence your choice, provide numerous examples of color combinations, and explore the best practices to help you confidently choose shingle colors for your Minnesota or Wisconsin home. We’ll discuss regional considerations, the latest trends, and practical tips to ensure your new roof not only looks great but also enhances the longevity of your investment.


1. Consider Your Home’s Exterior Colors

Your shingle color should complement your siding, trim, and exterior features to create a cohesive look. For example, dark shingles contrast beautifully with white siding common in the Midwest, while warm browns pair well with cabins and lake homes. If your house features brick accents, consider earthy tones like deep reds or muted greys that harmonize with the brick. Alternatively, if you have a more modern aesthetic with bold colors, you might explore sleek black or charcoal shingles to maintain a contemporary feel.


2. Think About Curb Appeal

Whether you live in a quiet Twin Cities suburb or a historic Wisconsin neighborhood, your shingle color can help your home stand out or blend in harmoniously with the surroundings. Consider how your home fits into its environment. In a neighborhood of traditional homes, opting for a classic shingle color may enhance your property’s appeal. Conversely, if your area features more eclectic designs, a bold color choice might set your home apart in a positive way.


3. Factor in Climate and Energy Efficiency

Minnesota and Wisconsin winters bring heavy snow, and darker shingles can help with snow melt, while lighter shingles can reduce heat absorption during humid summers. It’s worth considering Energy Star-rated shingles that reflect sunlight, which can help keep your home cooler in summer. Moreover, understanding how different colors respond to your local climate can guide you toward a color that balances comfort and efficiency, ultimately lowering your energy bills.


4. Check HOA Guidelines and Neighborhood Aesthetic

Many neighborhoods have HOA guidelines, and even if yours does not, considering the aesthetic of surrounding homes ensures your choice boosts long-term property value. It’s advisable to review any restrictions on color palettes and styles from your HOA to avoid potential fines or the hassle of re-roofing. Moreover, selecting a color that complements nearby homes can enhance neighborhood cohesion and maintain property values.


5. View Samples in Different Lighting

Because the Midwest experiences cloudy days, sunny days, and heavy snowfall, viewing samples outdoors in various conditions helps you understand how the color will look year-round. Consider bringing home a few samples and placing them against your home at different times of the day; this allows you to see how natural light affects colors at dawn, midday, and dusk, ensuring your choice will look appealing regardless of the conditions.


6. Consider Architectural Style

Choose colors that match your home’s style, whether it’s a craftsman in St. Paul, a modern Minnetonka lake home, or a traditional farmhouse in Oshkosh. Each architectural style has characteristics that can favor specific color palettes; for instance, a modern home may benefit from sleek, monochromatic shingles, while more traditional styles might shine with richer, warmer tones.


7. Ask for Expert Guidance

At Home Front Exteriors, we bring shingle samples to your home and help you see options in natural light before you decide. Our experts can guide you through the selection process, ensuring you consider every important aspect, from functionality and aesthetics to local regulations.


Ready to Refresh Your Roof?

If you’re considering a new roof and want help choosing the perfect shingle color, contact Home Front Exteriors for a free consultation. We proudly serve homeowners across Minnesota and Wisconsin, helping protect your home while bringing your exterior vision to life. Our team is equipped with the knowledge and tools necessary to assist you in making the best choice for your property’s needs.

Contact us today to schedule your free inspection and shingle color consultation! We are here to help you navigate through the exciting process of selecting the right shingle colors, ensuring your home looks beautiful and is well protected for years to come. Together, we can help you choose shingle colors that truly reflect your unique style and the charm of your neighborhood.

SHARE THIS ARTICLE:

[novashare_inline_content]
happy family roofing homefront exteriors eagan minnesota

Your Dream
Exterior Awaits.

Get In Touch